Understanding the birth of mass education, the IQ system, and why creativity will save our future


einstein-exam-cartoon

Frustration, from my understanding, stems from a lack of understanding. The notion is simple: If we take a problem, like the current state of mass education, and understand its history, functionality, and birth, we can then focus on the solution instead of relentlessly pointing fingers and blaming millennials. In the beginning of 2013, I set out to write a book on self-education — a meditation on how I adapted around rote education and set on a didactic pursuit of learning subjects that deeply interested me and fueled my aspirations and work. Self-education — particularly devouring books, blogs, finding the right teachers, listening to interviews and podcasts, and learning by doing — became a source of self-awareness, clarity, purpose, understanding, and joy. What was meant to be a guide ended up as a rant on the shortcomings of our educational systems. This wasn’t my intention, nor does it truly help anyone without providing the right kind of history and patterns.

I put the book on hold because I realized that my writing was reflecting a lack of understanding. And as always, when I fail to understand a subject or issue, I read books to absorb the perspective of those who are much smarter and experienced than I am. Out of Our Minds: Learning to Be Creative, written by Sir Ken Robinson — a champion of creativity and a leader of change and innovation in education — served as the panacea to my lack of understanding on why the education system is the way it is. Providing rich history, facts, patterns, and solutions, Out of Our Minds is a must-read for anyone who shares the frustrations that I once had (and still do because the change I desire will probably happen over many decades, if at all).

Let’s wind the clock back and start with the root of mass education and how the Industrial Era played a role in the schools we see today. Robinson says:

“The rise of industrialism generated enormous new streams of wealth and an entirely new social force: the wealthy and aspiring middle class. Education was seen as the essential route to social improvement and further economic opportunity. Education was also vital to generate the conditions for long-term economic prosperity. The growth of public education was shaped around the interests of the middle class, and their ambition not only for themselves but also for the industrialized societies they were helping to create. For the first time, industrialism provided the financial resources to pay for systems of mass education.

Many of us have a belief that education’s job is to shape us perfectly so that we may enter our careers prepared and willing — while also being good human beings. We believe that school should make us smart, well-rounded, and so much more. Robinson provides a compelling argument on why that was never the intentions of mass education [emphasis by me]:

“Education is not an impartial process of developing people’s natural abilities and it never was. Systems of mass education are built on two pillars. The first is economic: they have been shaped by specific assumptions about labor markets, many of which are now hopefully out of date. The second is intellectual: they have also been shaped by particular ideas about academic intelligence, which disregard other abilities that are just as important, especially for creativity and innovation. Perhaps the most powerful indicator of the need for transformation is the phenomenon of academic inflation.”

…

“The political impetus to develop national systems of education was not purely philanthropic or humanitarian: it was also economic. It arose out of the surging demands of the Industrial Revolution. The education systems that emerged were not only designed in the interests of industrialism, they were created in its image in terms of both structure and culture.“

As Seth Godin said, “A dozen generations ago, there was no unemployment, largely because there were no real jobs to speak of. Before the industrial revolution, the thought that you’d leave your home and go to an office or a factory was, of course, bizarre.”

Robinson goes and explains how schools are built like factories, and just by pausing and observing what we see today, the comparison is all too familiar and shocking:

“The rise of industrialism influenced not only the structure of mass education but also its organizational culture. Like factories, schools are special facilities with clear boundaries that separate them from the outside world. They have set hours of operation and prescribed rules of conduct. They are based on the principles of standardization and conformity. Students within the academic system are taught broadly the same material and they are assessed against common scales of achievement, with relatively few opportunities for choice or deviation. Typically, they move through the system in age groups: all the five-year-olds together, all the six-year-olds together and so on, as if the most important thing that children have in common is their date of manufacture. In high schools, the day is organized into standard units of time and the transitions are marked by the ringing of bells or buzzers. Teaching is based on the division of labor. Like an assembly line, students progress from room to room to be taught by different teachers specializing in different disciplines.”

With this newfound system to educate the masses arose an interesting invention: the IQ test. Robinson explains the birth of the IQ system:

“Like the motor car, television, the micro-processor and the Coca-Cola bottle, IQ is one of the most compelling inventions of the modern world. It is an idea in four parts. The first is that each of us is born with a fixed intellectual capacity or quotient: that just as we may have brown eyes or red hair, we have a set amount of intelligence. Second, how much intelligence we have can be calculated by a series of pencil-and-paper tests of the sort illustrated above. The results can be compared against a general scale and given as a number from 0 to 200. That number is your IQ. On this scale, average intelligence is between 80 and 100; above average is between 100 and 120 and anything above 130 gets you into Mensa’s Christmas party. The third idea is that IQ tests can be used to predict children’s performances at school and in later life. For this reason, IQ tests are widely used for school selection and educational planning. Finally, IQ is taken to be an index of general intelligence: that is, these tests are assumed to point to a person’s overall intellectual capacities. Many people now seem to think that it is enough to roll out their IQ score for everyone to grasp how bright they are, or not. As a result of all this, the popular idea of intelligence has become dangerously narrow and other intellectual abilities are either ignored or underestimated. For all these reasons, since the idea of IQ emerged about 100 years ago, it has had explosive consequences for social policy and especially for education.”

After reading all of this, I was astonished by how little I knew about a system that was responsible for my growth and upbringing. The same goes for parents: many parents don’t have a clue about any of this. The popular notion that sending your kid to school because it’s perhaps the best thing for them is easy to conform to — especially if you have work from 6 to 6. How often do people take the time to ask, What is school for? How many parents are forcing their kids to succumb to the mediocrity of rote memorization to score highly on a meaningless test? How much time is being wasted on the delusion of the concept of education?

This faulty belief of the IQ system spawned other cultural ways of thinking. Robinson explains:

“IQ has been used to support and to attack theories of racial, ethical and social difference. Early IQ tests in the UK and the USA suggested that poor people and their children have low IQs and that the rich and their offspring have high IQs. It seemed that IQ somehow determined levels of affluence and of material success. An important variable of course is that poor people could not afford to educate themselves and rich people could, which is something of an oversight from a methodological point of view. For a time, these findings provided a powerful rationale for political initiatives based on eugenics, to ‘improve’ the human stock by selective breeding and population control. In the early 20th century, leading intellectuals including Winston Churchill and George Bernard Shaw supported the eugenics movement, arguing that breeding of the poor should be carefully controlled. Some states in the USA legislated to sterilize people classified as ‘idiots’ or of low intelligence. With different motives, the Third Reich embraced eugenics as a key element in the Final Solution, with appalling ramifications.”

He continues with [emphasis by me]:

“From the outset, IQ has been a powerful and provocative idea, and it remains so, even though there is no general agreement on exactly what IQ tests measure, or on how, whatever it is they do measure, relates to general intelligence. Nonetheless, these ideas of academic ability and of IQ have come to be taken for granted as the natural order of things, rather than as the product of particular cultural values and scientific assumptions, which they are.”

It fascinates me how in one period of time a culture believed in one thing, and maybe a few decades or centuries later it’s flipped upside down—or maybe for worse, it remains the same. The question of high IQ and standardized testing still permeates throughout our culture of education, and therefore hindering student’s creativity and desire to actually learn something worth learning. At times, it sickens me. Watching my own younger brother being pressured to obtain a high GPA and SAT scores, I constantly remind him that there is an alternative to learning, one that is stimulating, interesting, and fun. I remind him to not lose sight of actual learning, and to fight against the distaste of the process. Sometimes we must serve first in order to lead.

Sir Ken Robinson on the need for championing creativity in organizations in order to survive:

“The consequences of a lack of creativity can be severe. Organizations that still stand are likely to be swept aside, and corporate history is littered with the wreckage of companies, and whole industries, that have been resistant to change. They became stuck in old habits and missed the waves of change that carried more innovative companies forward. … All organizations are organic and perishable. They are created by people and they need to be constantly re-created if they are to survive. When organizations fail, the jobs and communities that depend on them falter too. In a world where lifelong employment in the same job is a thing of the past, creativity is not a luxury. It is essential for personality security and fulfillment.”

I’ll end with a favorite passage of mine, one where Sir Ken Robinson explains the task of education, and why the tone of our voices matter when it comes to admonishing our children and younger generation [emphasis by me]:

“The task of education is not to teach subjects: it is to teach students. No school is better than its teachers. When you think of your own time at school it is the people you remember: your contemporaries, and especially the teachers: the ones who turned you on and the ones who turned you off; who built you up or knocked you down. In the right context, a casual remark by a teacher, or even a raised eyebrow or tone of voice can set you on a lifelong journey of discovery or put you off taking even the first step.“

Out of Our Minds: Learning to Be Creative is a thoughtful, timeless, enriching eye-opener on the nature of our education system and all that is involved. Robinson teaches us how to be creative — a innate gift that was slowly squeezed out of us. It’s a reminder that times are changing at an alarmingly quick rate due to technology and it’s our responsibility to adapt — not complain about what isn’t right. After putting the book down, I realize that my frustrations aren’t completely alleviated, but a deeper understanding allows me to focus on the solution to the problem, and to finally finish my book that will help people adapt and reconnect to a love for learning.

Additional videos by Sir Ken Robinson on education: