Improve your cognitive toolkit: 10 ways to think like a scientist
Lately I have developed a newfound love for curated books. Debbie Millman gave us perspectives from a variety of experts on the concept of brands. 99u gave us advice on how to be more productive, why deliberate practice is essential, and how to take smart risks. What I particularly love about these kind of books is that they provide rich perspectives from not just one author but from many. This helps us expand our worldview, weigh opinions, and challenges us to think more deeply about the wide range of information that can conflict or augment one another. The latest addition is a topic that has been untouched on this blog, until now: science.
John Brockman, founder and publisher of Edge.org and also the editor for This Will Make You Smarter, compiles a variety of thoughts from influential leaders in psychology, philosophy, economics, astronomy, physics, and more, to improve our cognitive toolkit. In this gem, thinkers like Daniel Kahneman, Richard Dawkins, Helen Fisher, and Aubrey De Grey share one concept or idea to help us think more scientifically.
Every year Brockman asks an annual question on Edge — like what should we be worried about and how is the internet changing the way you think — and gets answers from the most brilliant minds of our time. This type of knowledge is invaluable because it’s so rich in perspective, expertise, and understanding. Think about it: How else would you get this kind of information if it weren’t for books or the vast resources on the web? Although I haven’t devoured all of his books just yet, I’m glad I started with This Will Make You Smarter.
Below, I will share 10 different thinkers and their one tool that can improve our cognitive toolkit that will ultimately make us smarter.
1. Richard Dawkins, evolutionary zoologist, talks about the double-blind control experiment:
“We are looking for tools to help nonscientists understand science better and equip them to make better judgements throughout their lives.
Why do half of all Americans believe in ghosts, three-quarters believe in angels, a third believe in astrology, three-quarters believe in hell? Why do a quarter of all Americans believe that the president of the United States was born outside of the country and is therefore ineligible to be president? Why do more than 40 percent of Americans think the universe began after the domestication of dogs?
Let’s not give the defeatist answer and blame it all on stupidity. That’s probably part of the story, but let’s be optimistic and concentrate on something remediable: lack of training in how to think critically and how to discount personal opinion, prejudice, and anecdote in favor of evidence. I believe that the double-blind control experiment does double duty. It is more than just an excellent research tool. It also has educational, didactic value in teaching people how to think critically. My thesis is that you needn’t actually do a double-blind control experiments in order to experience an improvement in your cognitive toolkit. You need only understand the principle, grasp why it is necessary, and revel in its elegance.”
2. Max Tegmark, physicist and researcher, on promoting a scientific lifestyle:
“Despite spectacular success in research, our global scientific community has been nothing short of a spectacular failure when it comes to educating the public. Haitians burned twelve ‘witches’ in 2010. In the United States, recent polls show that 39 percent consider astrology scientific and 40 percent believe that our human species is less than ten thousand years old. If everyone understood the concept of ‘scientific concept,’ these percentages would be zero. Moreover, the world would be a better place, since people with a scientific lifestyle, basing their decisions on correct information, maximize their chances of success. By making rational buying and voting decisions, they also strengthen the scientific approach to decision making in companies, organizations, and governments.”
3. Timo Hannay on controlled experiments and how they help us get closer to the truth:
“When they are required to make a decision, the instinctive response of most nonscientists is to introspect, or perhaps call a meeting. The scientific method dictates that wherever possible we should instead conduct a suitable controlled experiment. The superiority of the latter approach is demonstrated not only by the fact that science has uncovered so much about the world but also, and even more powerfully, by the fact that such a lot of it — the Copernican Principle, evolution by natural selection, general relativity, quantum mechanics — is so mind-bendingly counterintuitive. Our embrace of truth as defined by experiment (rather than by common sense, or consensus, or seniority, or revelation, or any other means) has, in effect, released us from the constraints of our own innate preconceptions, prejudices, and lack of imagination. It has freed us to appreciate the universe in terms well beyond our abilities to derive by intuition alone.”
4. Kathryn Schulz, a journalist and author, on the pessimistic meta-induction from the history of science:
“Here’s the gist: Because so many scientific theories from bygone eras have turned out to be wrong, we must assume that most of today’s theories will eventually prove incorrect as well. And what goes for science goes in general. Politics, economics, technology, law, religion, medicine, child rearing, education: No matter the domain of life, one generation’s verities so often become the next generation’s falsehoods that we might as well have a pessimistic meta-induction from the history of everything.
Good scientists understand this. They recognize that they are part of a long process of approximation. They know that they are constructing models rather than revealing reality. They are comfortable working under conditions of uncertainty — not just the local uncertainty of “Will this data bear out my hypothesis?” but the sweeping uncertainty of simultaneously pursuing and being cut off from absolute truth.
The rest of us, by contrast, often engage in a kind of tacit chronological exceptionalism. Unlike all those suckers who fell for the flat Earth or the geocentric universe or cold fusion, we ourselves have the great good luck to be alive during the very apex of accurate human thought. The literary critic Harry Levin put this nicely: ‘The habit of equating one’s age with the apogee of civilization, one’s town with the hub of the universe, one’s horizons with the limits of human awareness, is paradoxically widespread.’
[…]
The idea behind the meta-induction is that all of our theories are fundamentally provisional and quite possible wrong. If we can add that to our cognitive toolkit, we will be better able to listen with curiosity and empathy to those whose theories contradict our own. We will be better able to pay attention to counter evidence — those anomalous bits of data that make our picture of the world a little weirder, more mysterious, less clean, less done. And we will be able to hold our own beliefs a bit more humbly, in the happy knowledge that better ideas are almost certainly on the way.”
5. Richard Nisbett, social psychologist, on “Graceful” SHAs and how it helps us make better decisions:
“1. A university needs to replace its aging hospital. Cost estimates indicate that it would be as expensive to remodel the old hospital as to demolish it and build a new one from scratch. The main argument offered by the proponents of the former is that the original hospital was very expensive to build and it would be wasteful to simply demolish it. The main argument of the proponents of a new hospital is that a new hospital would inevitably be more modern than a remodeled one. Which seems wiser to you — remodel or build a new hospital?
[…]
Question 1: If you said that the university should remodel on the grounds that it was expensive to build the old hospital, you have fallen into the ‘sunk-cost trap’ shorthand abstraction (SHA) identified by economists. The money spent on the hospital is irrelevant — it’s sunk — and has no bearing on the present choice. Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman pointed out that people’s ability to avoid such traps might be helped by a couple of thought experiments like the following:
Imagine that you have two tickets to tonight’s NBA game in your city and that the arena is forty miles away. But it’s begun to snow, and you’ve found out that your team’s star has been injured and won’t be playing. Should you go, or just throw away the money and skip it?
To answer this question as an economist would, ask yourself the following question: ‘Suppose you didn’t have the tickets to the game, and a friend called you up and said he had two tickets to tonight’s game which he couldn’t use, and asked if you’d like to have them. If the answer is, ‘You’ve got to be kidding. It’s snowing and the star isn’t playing,’ then the answer is that you shouldn’t go. That answer shows you that the fact that you paid good money for the tickets you have is irrelevant —their cost is sunk and can’t be retrieved by doing something that you don’t want to do anyway. Avoidance of sunk-cost trap is a religion for economists, but I find that a single college course in economics actually does little to make people aware of the sunk-cost trap. It turns out that exposure to a few basketball-type anecdotes does a lot.”
6. Neil Gershenfeld on truth being a model:
“The most common misunderstanding about science is that scientists seek and find truth. They don’t — they make and test models. Kepler; packing Platonic solids to explain the observed motion of planets, made pretty good predictions, which were improved by his laws of planetary motion, which were improved by Newton’s laws of motion, which were improved by Einstein’s general relativity. Kepler didn’t become wrong because Newton’s being right, just as Newton didn’t then become wrong because of Einstein’s being right; these successive models differed in their assumptions, accuracy, and applicability, not in their truth.
This is entirely unlike the polarizing battles that define so many areas of life: Either my political party, or religion, or lifestyle, is right or yours is, and I believe in mine. The only thing that’s shared is the certainty of infallibility.
Building models is very different from proclaiming truths. It’s a never-ending process of discovery and refinement, not a war to win or destination to reach. Uncertainty is intrinsic to the process of finding out what you don’t know, not a weakness to avoid. Bugs are features — violations of expectations are opportunities to refine them. And decisions are made by evaluating what works better, not by invoking received wisdom.
These are familiar aspects of the work of any scientist, or baby: It’s not possible to learn to talk or walk without babbling or toddling to experiment with language and balance. Babies who keep babbling turn into scientists who formulate and test theories for a living. But it doesn’t require professional training to make mental models — we’re born with those skills. What’s needed is not displacing them with the certainty of absolute truths that inhibit the exploration of ideas. Making sense of anything means making models that can predict outcomes and accommodate observations. Truth is a model.”
7. Carlo Rovelli, physicist, on the uselessness of uncertainty and the goals of science:
“There is a widely held notion that does plenty of damage: the notion of ‘scientifically proven.’ Nearly an oxymoron. The very foundation of science is to keep the door open to doubt. Precisely because we keep questioning everything, especially our own premises, we are always ready to improve our knowledge. Therefore a good scientist is never ‘certain.’ Lack of certainty is precisely what makes conclusions more reliable than the conclusions of those who are certain, because the good scientist will be ready to shift to a different point of view if better evidence or novel arguments emerge. Therefore certainty is not only something of no use but is also in fact damage, if we value reliability.
Failure to appreciate the value of uncertainty is at the origin of much silliness in our society. Are we sure that the Earth is going to keep heating up if we don’t do anything? Are we sure of the details of the current theory of evolution? Are we sure that modern medicine is always a better strategy than traditional ones? No, we are not, in any of these cases. But if, from this lack of certainty, we jump to the conviction that we had better not care about global heating, that there is no evolution and the world was created six thousand years ago, or that traditional medicine must be more effective than modern medicine — well, we are simply stupid. Still, many people do make these inferences, because the lack of certainty is perceived as a sign of weakness instead of being what it is — the first source of our knowledge.”
8. Daniel Kahneman on the focusing illusion:
“The mismatch in the allocation of attention between thinking about a life condition and actually living it is the cause of the focusing illusion.
Marketers exploit the focusing illusion. When people are induced to believe that they ‘must have’ a good, they great exaggerate the difference that the good will make to the quality of their life. The focusing illusion is greater for some goods than for others, depending on the extent to which the goods attract continued attention over time. The focusing illusion is likely to be more significant for leather car seats than for books on tape.
Politicians are almost as good as marketers in causing people to exaggerate the important of issues on which their attention is focused. People can be made to believe that school uniforms will significantly improve educational outcomes, or that health care reform will hugely change the quality of life in the United States — either for the better or for the worse. Health care reform will make a difference, but the difference will be smaller than it appears when you focus on it.”
9. David G. Myers, social psychologist, on self-serving bias:
“Most of us have a good reputation with ourselves. That’s the gist of a sometimes amusing and frequently perilous phenomenon that social psychologists call self-serving bias.
Accepting more responsibility for success than for failure, for good deeds than for bad.
In experiments, people readily accept credit when told they have succeed, attributing it to their ability and effort. Yet they attribute failure to such external factors as bad luck or the problem’s ‘impossibility.’ When we win at Scrabble, it’s because of our verbal dexterity. When we lose, it’s because ‘I was stuck with a Q but no U.’
[…]
Studies of self-serving bias and its cousins — illusory optimism, self-justification, and in-group bias — reminds us of what literature and religion have taught: Pride often goes before a fall. Perceiving ourselves and our group favorably protects us against depression, buffers stress, and sustains our hopes. But it does so at the cost of martial discord, bargaining impasses, condescending prejudice, national hubris, and war. Being mindful of self-serving bias beckons us not to false modesty but a humility that affirms our genuine talents and virtues and likewise those of others.”
10. Gino Segre on the use of gedankenexperiments, or thought experiments:
“However, the subject need not be an esoteric one for a gedankenexperiment to be fruitful. My own favorite is Galileo’s proof that, contrary to Aristotle’s view, objects of different mass fall in a vacuum with the same acceleration. One might think that a real experiment needs to be conducted to test that hypothesis, but Galileo simply asked us to consider a large and small stone tied together by a very light string. If Aristotle was right, the large stone should speed up the smaller one, and the smaller one retard the larger one, if they fall at different rates. However, if you let the string length approach zero, you have a single object with a mass equal to the sum of their masses, and hence it should gal at a higher rate than either. This is nonsensical. The conclusion is that all objects fall in a vacuum at the same rate.
Consciously or unconsciously, we carry out gedankenexperiments of one sort or another in our everyday life and are even trained to perform them in a variety of disciplines, but it would be useful to have greater awareness of how they are conducted and how they can be positively applied. We could ask, when confronted with a puzzling situation, ‘How can I set up a gedankenexperiment to resolve the issue?’ Perhaps our financial, political, and military experts would benefit from following such a tactic — and arrive at happier outcomes.”
This Will Make You Smarter has many more influential thinkers that provide a diversity of tools to improve how you think. Carlo Rovelli said something that’s worth repeating [emphasis by me]: “There is a widely held notion that does plenty of damage: the notion of ‘scientifically proven.’ Nearly an oxymoron. The very foundation of science is to keep the door open to doubt.” I love that, because it’s easy to assume that the purpose of science is to dispel any doubts and to pave the road to certainty. I must admit, part of me believed that for a long time — for most of my life — until recently. It goes to show how learning to embrace other people’s perspectives can help you clean the lens through which you view the world.