Greatness debunked: the science behind talent and skill acquisition

“If I skip practice for one day, I notice. If I skip practice for two days, my wife notices. If I skip practice for three days, the world notices.” — Vladamir Horowitz

The cultural language surrounding talent is far too inaccurate, creating a fixed self-undermining belief on what it means to be talented or skilled. The common belief for talent is that it is something you’re born with—that you’re born a painter, athlete, or writer—rather than viewing it as a muscle that can grow with time and practice. The very thought of picking up an instrument in your latter 30s or learning a new language in your 40s is often viewed as ridiculous—it’s too late! Such beliefs are at the heart of why people never try, and in turn, actualize.

Daniel Coyle, author of The Talent Code: Greatness Isn’t Born. It’s Grown. Here’s How, debunks the mythology surrounding talent and greatness. By providing brain research, stories of working with world-class coaches, and psychological research, Coyle provides a refreshing and scientific-based view on what talent is and why it is grown, not something ingrained in our genes. But before we get into it, let’s acknowledge the grey area: Indeed, some of us are born with a proclivity for numbers, colors, shapes, or words. Some of us are more fit for designing a ball instead of dunking one. This thing—call it passion or inclination or predisposition—is obviously helpful to identify at an early age and to relentlessly feed it with apprenticeships, good coaching, and hearty practice. Of course, many young individuals fail to get that kind of nurturing early in life, but the notion of “never too late” stands strong—at least that’s what science says.

In the words of Daniel Coyle [emphasis by me]:

“The talent code is built on revolutionary scientific discoveries involving a neural insulator called myelin, which some neurologists now consider to be the holy grail of acquiring skill. Here’s why. Every human skill, whether it’s playing baseball or playing Bach, is created by chains of nerve fibers carrying a tiny electrical impulse—basically, a signal traveling through a circuit. Myelin’s vital role is to wrap those nerve fibers the same way that rubber insulation wraps a copper wire, making the signal stronger and faster by preventing electrical impulses from leaking out. When we fire our circuits in the right way—when we practice swinging that bat or playing that note—our myelin responds by wrapping layers of insulation around that neural circuit, each new layer adding a bit more skill and speed. The thicker the myelin gets, the better it insulates, and the faster and more accurate our movements and thoughts become.”

Then Coyle talks about the science behind myelin, and shares the mantra of this book:

“Myelin is important for several reasons. It’s universal: everyone can grow it, most swiftly during childhood but also throughout out. It’s indiscriminate: its growth enables all manners of skills, mental and physical. It’s imperceptible: we can’t see it or feel it, and we can sense its increase only by its magical—seeming effect. Most of all, however, myelin is important because it provides us with a vivid new model for understanding skill. Skill is a cellular insulation that wraps neural circuits and that grows in response to certain signals.”

To go deeper into the myelin, we must understand its 4 laws:

“1. The firing of the circuit is paramount. Myelin is not built to respond to fond wishes or vague ideas or information that washes over us like a warm bath. The mechanism is built to respond to actions: the literal electrical impulses traveling down nerve fibers. It responds to urgent repetition. In a few chapters we’ll discuss the likely evolutionary reasons, but for now we’ll simply note that deep practice is assisted by the attainment of a primal state, one where we are attentive, hungry, and focused, even desperate.

2. Myelin is universal. One size fits all skills. Our myelin doesn’t ‘know’ whether it’s being used for playing shortstop or playing Schubert: regardless of its use, it grows according to the same rules. Myelin is meritocratic: circuits that fire get insulated. If you moved to China, your myelin would wrap fibers that help you learn to speak Mandarin. To put it another way, myelin doesn’t care who you are—it cares what you do.

3. Myelin wraps—it doesn’t unwrap. Like a highway-paving machine, myelination happens in one direction. Once a skill circuit is insulated, you can’t un-insulate it (except through age or disease). That’s why habits are hard to break. The only way to change them is to build new habits by repeating new behaviors—by myelinating new circuits.

4. Age matters. In children, myelin arrives in a series of waves, some of them determined by genes, some dependent on activity. The waves last into our thirties, creating critical periods during which time the brain is extraordinarily receptive to learning new skills. Thereafter we continue to experience a net gain of myelin until around the age of fifty, when the balance tips towards loss. We retain the ability to myelinate throughout life—thankfully, 5 percent of our oligos remain immature, always ready to answer the call. But anyone who has tried to learn a new language or a musical instrument later in life can testify that it takes a lot more time and sweat to build and requisite circuity. This is why the vast majority of world class experts start young. Their genes do not change as they grow older, but their ability to build myelin does.”

I can understand why it’s difficult to view skill through this lens. It’s easier to view skill as something that is a natural expression of the person, something so effortless, instead of realizing that their expression of the skill is grown from practice and passion.

To understand skill acquisition, we should look at the brain and the three simple facts [emphasis by me]:

“Like most people, I was under the impression that the key to learning skills and being human resided in our brain’s neurons, that flickering web of interconnected nerve fibers and the famous synapses through which they link and communicate. But Fields, Bartzokis, and others informed me that while they still consider neurons and synapses to be vitally important, the traditional neuron-centric worldview is being fundamentally altered by a Copernican-size revolution. This humble-looking insulation, it turns out, plays a key role in the way our brains function, particularly when it comes to acquiring skills.

The revolution is built on three simple facts. (1) Every human movement, thought, or feeling is a precisely timed electric signal traveling through a chain of neurons—a circuit of nerve fibers. (2) Myelin is the insulation that wraps these nerve fibers and increases signal strength, speed, and accuracy. (3) The more we fire a particular circuit, the more myelin optimizes that circuit, and the stronger, faster, and more fluent our movements and thoughts become.”

Now let’s look at the biology behind it:

“All actions are really the result of electrical impulses sent along chains of nerve fibers. Basically, our brains are bundles of wires—100 billion wires called neurons, connected to each other by synapses. Whenever you do something, your brain sends a signal through those chains of nerve fibers to your muscles. Each time you practice anything—sing a tune, swing a club, read this sentence—a different highly specific circuit lights up in my mind, sort of like a string of Christmas lights. The simplest skill—say, a tennis backhand—involves a circuit made up of hundreds of thousands of fibers and synapses.

[…]

In a profound way the circuit is the movement: it dictates the precise strength and timing of each muscle contraction, the shape and content of each thought. A sluggish, unreliable circuit means a sluggish, unreliable movement; on the other hand, a fast, synchronous circuit means a fast, synchronous movement.”

“The more we develop a skill circuit, the less we’re aware that we’re using it. We’re built to make skills automatic, to stash them in our unconscious mind. This process, which is called automaticity, exists for powerful evolutionary reasons. (The more processing we can do in our unconscious minds, the better our chances of noticing saber-toothed tigers lurking in the bush). It also creates a powerfully convincing illusion: a skill, once gained, feels utterly normal, as if it’s something we’ve always possessed.”

It’s easy to gawk at talented individuals, instead of looking at their track record of failure, deep practice, coaching, and an entire lifetime spent honing that skill. For example, the stereotype behind Brazilians being excellent at soccer is an interesting observation indeed. But Coyle spent some time in Brazil, speaking to coaches and players, and realized that many of the greats are great because they grew up playing a game called futsal, although it isn’t the only reason. In essence, it’s about deep practice but also the way they practice:

“One reason lies in the math. Futsal players touch the ball far more often than soccer players—six times more often per minute, according to a Liverpool University study. The smaller, heavier ball demands and rewards more precise handling—as coaches point out, you can’t get out of a tight spot simply by booting the ball downfield. Sharp passing is paramount: the game is all about looking for angles and spaces and working quick combinations with other players.

[…]

In other words, Brazilian soccer is different from the rest of the world’s because Brazil employs the sporting equivalent of a Link trainer [Note from me: The Link trainer is a story about a man who invented a device that taught pilots how to fly without actually flying, reducing the causality rates while also providing an opportunity to hone skills]. Futsal compresses soccer’s essential skills into a small box; it places players inside the deep practice zone, making and correcting errors, constantly generating solutions to vivid problems. Players touching the ball 600 percent more often learn far faster, without realizing it, than they would in the vast, bouncy expanse of the outdoor game. To be clear: futsal is not the only reason Brazilian soccer is great. The other factors so often cited—climate, passion, and poverty—really do matter. But futsal is the lever through which those other factors transfer their force”

What this boils down to is a concept that you may be familiar with or heard about: deep practice and the 10,000 hour rule. The notion that it takes approximately 10,000 hours to master a skill has become a benchmark in culture. There is validity to that study, but it doesn’t complete the picture:

“Its central tenet is a Gibraltar-like statistic: every expert in every field is the result of around ten thousand hours of committed practice. Ericsson called this process ‘deliberate practice’ and definite it was working on technique, seeking constant critical feedback, and focusing ruthlessly on shoring up weaknesses.”

“Deep practice feels a bit like exploring a dark and unfamiliar room. You start slowly, you bump into furniture, stop, think, and start again. Slowly, and a little painfully, you explore the space over and over, attending to errors, extending your reach into the room a bit farther each time, building a mental map until you can move through it quickly and intuitively.
[…]

In the talent hotbeds I visited, the chunking takes place in three dimensions. First, the participants look at the task as a whole—as one big chunk, the megacircuit. Second, they divide it into its smallest possible chunks. Third, they play with time, slowing the action down, then speeding it up, to learn its inner architecture. People in the hotbeds deep-practice the same way a good movie director approaches a scene—one instant panning back to show the landscape, the next zooming in to examine a bug crawling on a leaf in slo-mo.”

The reason why it’s so difficult to commit to deep practice is a lack of patience and the cultural fetishes of immediate gratification. So frustrating it is to do something so relentlessly, only to feel like we’ve never moved past square one. Although improvement is incremental and often seemingly invisible, deep practice is indeed the lifeblood of mastering any skill. Not only does it seem like common sense, it’s a science.

My favorite section of this book is when Coyle debunks and reveals some of the elements within savants, geniuses, or masters. He uses Mozart as an example, revealing the elements of deep practice, a fiery desire to learn, and good coaching, as well as returning to the 10,000 hour rule and what it really means—something that is available to us all:

“In Genius Explained, Dr. Michael Howe of Exeter University estimates that Mozart, by his sixth birthday, had studied 3,500 hours of music with his instructor-father, a fact that places his musical memory in the realm of impressive but obtainable skill. Savants tend to excel within narrow domains that feature clear, logical rules (piano and math—as opposed to, say, improvisational comedy or fiction writing). Furthermore, savants typically accumulate massive amounts of prior exposure to those domains, through such means as listening to music in the home. The true expertise of these geniuses, the research suggests, resides in their ability to deep-practice obsessively, even when it doesn’t necessarily look like they’re practicing. As Ericsson succinctly put it, ‘There’s no cell type that geniuses have that the rest of us don’t.’ That’s not to say that a minuscule percentage of people don’t possess an innate, obsessive desire to improve—what psychologist Ellen Winner calls ‘the rage to master.’ But these sorts of self-driven deep practicers are rare and are blazingly self-evident. (A rule of thumb: if you don’t have to ask whether your child possess the rage to master, he doesn’t.)

If we overlay Ericsson’s research with the new myelin science, we get something approaching a universal theory of skill that can be summed up in a temptingly concise equation: deep practice X 10,000 hours = world-class skill. But the truth is, life’s more complicated than that. The truth is, it’s better to use the information as a lens through which we can illuminate how the talent code works, to uncover hidden connections between distant worlds, to ask strange questions, like: what do the Brontë sisters have in common with skateboarders?”

A “rage to master.” I love that. I believe everyone has a capacity to have an obsessive desire to learn and improve, only if they find that craft or subject that deeply resonates with them, intrigues them, stimulates curiosity, has them wanting more and more even in the face of failure and hardship.

The last piece of this puzzle that grows talent is great coaching. Like Mozart and those Brazilian soccer players, they had someone who helped them spot their mistakes and provide essential feedback to foster improvement; but it’s also worth noting that they were probably very good at coaching themselves. By possessing an unquenchable desire to learn and improve, we can be self-reflective of our mistakes and learn from them too. Through repetition and deep practice, we can’t help but get better. Coyle shares an interesting study on self-regulation, people who coach themselves, and why the way we speak about our practice is a measure for expertise:

“Working with Anastasia Kitsantas of George Mason University, Zimmerman posed a question: Is it possible to judge ability solely by the way people describe the way they practice?

[…]

The skill Zimmerman and Kitsantas chose was a volleyball serve. They gathered a range of expert players, club players, and novices, and asked them how they approached the serve: their goals, planning, strategy choices, self-monitoring, and adaption—twelve measures in all. Using the answers, they predicted the players’ relative skill levels, then had the players execute their serve to test the accuracy of their predictions. The result? Ninety percent of the variation in skill could be accounted for by the players’ answers.

‘Our predictions were extremely accurate,’ Zimmerman said. ‘This showed that experts practice differently and far more strategically. When they fail, they don’t blame it on luck or themselves. They have a strategy they can fix.’”

***

What’s ultimately true for us is that deep practice and a mindset geared for recognizing mistakes and learning from them is at the heart of mastery. But are you willing to make mistakes? The reason why this mindset is so difficult to embrace is because the cultural language doesn’t promote patience, mindfulness, and wanting to fail—in fact, quite the opposite. It’s easy to see someone who is great at what they do and hopelessly label them “talented” or “genius” instead of appreciating the effort put into honing those skills, and realizing that we, too, are capable of achieving such feats.

Even if culture at large accepted this scientific-based view of talent—that you’re not born something but instead become it—what then? I think it would still be difficult to start simply because as a culture we have a fear of failure, we are impatient and want immediate rewards, and if there is no promise of making a great career out of it, why bother. But if you do have some itch to try something new—dancing, drawing, coding, writing, etc.—I implore you to give it a shot. It’ll be incredibly difficult to show up that day, to realize just how bad you are, but to somehow find joy and meaning in all of it. As long as you deeply practice—find your way in that dark room—and learn from your mistakes, you simply can’t fight science: you will improve. Over time, especially if it’s a subject or craft that deeply resonates with you, the process will become a joy in itself. The “rage to master” will be imminent. The desire to learn more, to improve, to go past your pinnacle will fill you with immense joy and meaning. Even better, you may make a life out of it.

The Talent Code has been one of my favorite books thus far in 2014 simply because the author does a masterful job of providing the right kind of insight and knowledge on a subject that has been deemed seemingly magical and mysterious. The research, storytelling, and structure of the book is excellent, helping any reader change their beliefs about what talent is, how it’s grown, and why the principles within are immediately applicable to our lives. The hardest part of this entire journey is starting something; the second hardest is committing.